Mon, Mar 03, 2008 Bookmark and Share eMail this Article Send Print this Article Print Media Kit Reprints RSS feeds RSS
U.S. educators seek lessons from Scandinavia
High-scoring nations on an international exam say success stems from autonomy, project-based learning

 

Primary Topic Channel:  Cross-cultural communication

 

A recent U.S. delegation toured Scandinavian countries for advice.

A delegation led by the Consortium for School Networking (CoSN) recently toured Scandinavia in search of answers for how students in that region of the world were able to score so high on a recent international test of math and science skills. They found that educators in Finland, Sweden, and Denmark all cited autonomy, project-based learning, and nationwide broadband internet access as keys to their success.

What the CoSN delegation didn’t find in those nations were competitive grading, standardized testing, and top-down accountability—all staples of the American education system.

As CoSN officials explained during a webcast held Feb. 27, the delegation traveled to Helsinki, Stockholm, and Copenhagen to talk with the ministries of education in each country and exchange ideas with local business and school leaders.

The group’s goal was to learn how these countries are approaching education, reaching students, involving teachers, and implementing policy. Specifically, CoSN wanted to see how strategic investment in information and communications technology (ICT) was affecting education in the region.

As in the United States, most Scandinavian classrooms are connected to the internet, students and teachers have access to computers, and there is an ample supply of online learning resources and virtual-schooling programs. However, according to Keith Krueger, CoSN’s chief executive, ICT in that area of the world “is supportive of programs, rather than a driving force, and is viewed as important primarily to ensure students’ success in their future careers.”

Kati Tuurala, Microsoft’s education manager in Finland—whose students scored the highest in both math and science on the latest Program for International Student Assessment (PISA)—said there is a “huge change in the knowledge economy because of the global market. In order to ensure future success, we need to know how to go from good to great.”

She credits Finland’s success to its major reforms of the 1970s, which included an emphasis on primary education for everyone in the country. “That’s the reason for our present-day success,” Tuurala said.

In all three countries, students start formal schooling at age seven after participating in extensive early-childhood and preschool programs focused on self-reflection and social behavior, rather than academic content. By focusing on self-reflection, students learn to become responsible for their own education, delegates said.

Barbara Stein, manager of external partnerships and advocacy for the National Education Association, said Scandinavian countries “encourage philosophical thought at a very young age. … Grading doesn’t happen until the high-school level, because they believe grading takes the fun out of learning. They want to inspire continuous learning.”

 
Continued
Pages: 1 2 3 | Next ››
 
 

Comment now.

Don't forget to check out our Online highlights:
- Discover new resources that help school leaders strengthen their school district inside our new Superintendents Center.
Go to http://www.eschoolnews.com/news/superintendents-center/
- View this week's Student Video News Cast at www.eschoolnews.tv where you can also upload video too!
- Follow eSchool News on Twitter at http://twitter.com/eschoolnews
- Add our RSS feeds or our new widgets to any school web site. Go to http://www.eschoolnews.com/content-exchange-rss/
- Find the latest news in the current issue of eSchool News. Go to http://www.eschoolnews.com/current/

smoke and mirrors

There are a number of problems with PISA, not the least is the fact that the tests are written by progressive educators. Hence, you are going to find a lot of questions on 'mathematical reasoning'--which typically have a trivial mathematical question buried under a lot of verbiage--and very few which require the student to solve difficult problems. A study by Sig Prais, one of Britain's leading authorities on educational evaluations, found that "The study questions were deliberately not related to the school curriculum. Rather they were to ‘real-life’ situations – such as the growth of lichen or the breathing cycles of seals, leading inevitably to significant misunderstandings across the socially disparate countries." Unsurprisingly, Scandanavian pupils do rather better on lichen and seals than do Singaporean students. See http://www.civitas.org.uk/pdf/CivitasReviewJan04.pdf Not only is the equivalence of tests across language barriers is extremely doubtful, but the selection of schools (and pupils) that participate is also problematical. England scored rather better than one would expect because there is no way our central government can force a school to participate, which meant that our sample was strongly skewed to the more able end of the spectrum. There are further problems with this analysis. Scandanavian languages are quite regular in terms of grapheme-phoneme correspondences, so most children learn to decode with fairly little fuss. And Anglophone schools aren't the models of traditional rigour they are made out to be in this article. England's National Curriculum looks quite traditional from the outside, but developmental philosophy still rules inside. Students are expected to meet learning objectives through exactly the kind of 'investigations' extolled in this article.

Posted By: tom burkard, 2008-04-01 6:18 AM

Learning From Scandinavian Countries

It is easy for various education stakeholders to latch onto fragments of this article and say: "we need a laissez-faire system!" or "we need to abandon High Stakes Testing!" This would be a big mistake. The Scandinavian system can flourish because the fabric of the society supports most to all citizens. There are not groups of citizens living in significant poverty nor groups living in lavish material wealth. A solid primary education for all is the societal expectation. Education starts with students learning self-reflection and social skills throughout early childhood. These critical societal foundations allow such an educational system to thrive! How does America mirror these societal foundations and expectations for all Americans?

Posted By: schiefjx, 2008-03-31 9:28 AM

Nothing convenient about this...

I had to respond to the above comment. I have blogged about this over at http://blog.brettmoller.com These conclusions are certainly not convenient for teachers. If you care to take some time and read what much of these changes require, you would notice that there is a call for teachers to not only be better supported and respected but be further trained and more qualified. It amazes me that folk who work in the corporate world are the last to realise that with respect and honour in a job comes highly qualified and effective workers. If we place more emphasis on the importance of education and respect on those who are experts in teaching and learning, as a society, we may begin to see what needs to change in order for our education systems to truly improve. Test scores and standard based testing is destroying true learning and the evidence is clearly here!!

Posted By: edtech914, 2008-03-30 6:52 AM

A rather convenient set of conclusions...

How surprising. A consortium of (primarily) educators finds that the key to success is to give educators more autonomy, to not hold them accountable via tests or standards, and to provide more resources.

Posted By: mbrianlars, 2008-03-28 4:07 PM

 

You need to be registered at eSchoolnews.com to add your comments. If you do not have a username / password please register here ! Registration is very simple and will not take much time!

 
Already registered? Login:
Username:  Want to know more?
Registation Benefits
Password: