Officials huddle on use of athletes’ images

Should video-game makers and organizers of fantasy sports leagues be allowed to profit from the use or likeness of college athletes? And if so, should the athletes themselves stand to benefit?

These questions were the subject of an Oct. 27 forum by the Knight Commission on Intercollegiate Athletics, whose members warned of the importance of protecting student athletes from commercial exploitation–especially as technology allows for the proliferation of new forms of media.

Some former college athletes who attended the forum argued that students should be free to decide how their name and likeness would be used–mostly because of the "coolness factor."

"I would be excited to see my likeness and playing abilities in an EA Sports game," said Marvin Lewis, associate athletics director at Georgia State University and former basketball player at Georgia Tech. He said many of his former teammates would feel the same way.

But commission members, as well as a panel of lawyers and media experts, said colleges could have a case to prevent media companies from creating fantasy leagues using their athletes’ names and likenesses.

"College athletes in fantasy games and video games may seem trivial to some, but these and other forms of new media pose new challenges to the long-held distinction between commercial activity featuring teams and that which focuses on individual athletes," said R. Gerald Turner, Knight Commission co-chairman and president of Southern Methodist University.

"We continue to believe that universities need to treat athletes fairly and equitably," Turner said, "and for third parties to use them in commercial products and advertisements violates that principle."

Panelist Jeffrey Mishkin, a partner with Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher, and Flom LLP and Affiliates, and former executive vice president and chief legal officer for the National Basketball Association, said a recent court case found that while the use of a professional athlete’s name and likeness was a violation of the player’s privacy rights, it didn’t outweigh the First Amendment rights of publishers to free speech.

Mishkin said that even though he doesn’t agree with the court’s ruling, he thinks student athletes should be examined differently.

He explained that a fantasy league can pay a publicity licensing fee to professional athletes, because in most cases professional athletes are looking for ways to maximize their earnings. However, student athletes are not allowed to accept a publicity licensing fee.

Legal experts and former college athletes agreed that while students should not be paid for playing a college sport, there could be other ways to support student athletes.

"The No. 1 monopoly in the United States is the NCAA," said Jeremy Bloom, a former football player for the University of Colorado and a world champion and Olympic snow skier. "College athletics is not amateur anymore."

Bloom, who sat on a panel of former athletes, said everyone knows that intercollegiate sports–especially football and basketball–are a for-profit entity. He said the money not only should be used to fund scholarships, but also could help pay for year-round medical insurance or be put toward graduate school tuition.

Commission member Len Elmore, who is an analyst for ESPN and a partner at Dreier LLP, said the link between commercialism and intercollegiate athletics might be inevitable, "given new technologies that are intersecting with consumer demand for interactivity and reality-based gaming."

"If college athletes’ names and likenesses are to be used in commercial products, advertisements, or fantasy sports games, there must be a way to balance the inequities by providing some sort of benefit to athletes through mechanisms other than ‘pay for play,’" Elmore said.

Panelist Wallace Renfro, vice president and senior advisor to the president of the NCAA, said the purpose of intercollegiate athletics is to provide an education–and the entertainment value assigned to a sport should not undermine that. While commercialism will always be part of intercollegiate athletics, Renfro said, the less commercialism that is seen, the better.

Renfro acknowledged that with technology constantly changing, it’s hard to create guidelines for the NCAA.

"We can’t rely on rules and regulations to harness the potential of new technologies and applications. We have to learn to depend on commonly held principles that guide rational application at national and campus levels," he said. "There needs to be a reaffirmation that a student’s likeness or name can’t be used for financial gain."


Knight Commission on Intercollegiate Athletics

Note to readers:

Don’t forget to visit the “ Creating the 21 st Century Classroom ”resource center. Preparing today’s youth to succeed in the digital economy requires a new kind of teaching and learning. Skills such as global literacy, computer literacy, problem solving, critical thinking, creativity, and innovation have become critical in today’s increasingly interconnected workforce and society–and technology is the catalyst for bringing these changes into the classroom. Go to Creating-the-21st-century-classroom


MEAF Inclusion Champion Award

The MEAF Inclusion Champion Award honors individuals who have made significant efforts to promote the full inclusion of youth with disabilities in society. The focus of the efforts may include, but is not limited to, helping to create a culture of inclusion within an organization or community or developing innovative strategies for inclusive programming in: school activities, after-school programs, community service, and leadership development.


Music Matters Grants

Music Matters Grants for 2009 will focus on educational reform in school music programs and independent music programs. Grants will be awarded in April 2009 to schools and music programs throughout the United States.


Being an American: 2008-2009 Essay Contest

Teachers and students can win cash and other prizes for submitting an essay on which civic value they believe is most essential to being an American.  In their essay, applicants are asked to trace the enduring importance of this value throughout the American story by discussing: a Founding document that reflects this value; a figure from American history who embodies this value; and ways the applicant can personally put this value into practice.


Teachers in Space Program

The Pathfinder program aims to help the first astronaut teachers fly in space and return to the classroom.  These Pathfinders will also help design the three-week training course for the large number of teachers who follow. We hope that Pathfinders also may have the opportunity to return each summer to help teach the course.  Currently, two positions for Pathfinders are open, for Pathfinders with strengths in STEM, and lesson plan development, with more slots to follow.  Applicants for the STEM Pathfinder slot are asked to submit a proposal for an experiment that could be performed on a suborbital flight.  Lesson plan development applications are asked to submit a lesson plan or curriculum module based on any aspect of human spaceflight. Teachers from all subject areas, STEM and non-STEM, are encouraged to apply.


The Big Read

This grant revitalizes the role of literature in American popular culture. Grants are available to encourage local communities to inspire reading by developing and carrying out programming revolving around a single work of literature. Programming must be conducted between September 2009 and June 2010.  Big Read grants require the participation of a library as a lead applicant or a partner.


USA TODAY All-USA College Academic Team

This annual program honors full-time undergraduates who not only excel academically but also extend their intellectual abilities beyond the classroom to benefit society. Students named to the USA TODAY All-USA College Academic First Team will be featured in USA TODAY in March 2009 and will receive trophies and cash awards of $2,500.  Students must be nominated by their schools and be willing to be presented in USA TODAY as a representative of all outstanding students.  Schools may nominate as many students as they consider appropriate candidates for this award.


My Class Project(or)

This video contest gives K-12 classes nationwide the opportunity to win a new 3M SCP712 Projection System for their classroom. The student or class will need to produce and submit a video 1-3 minutes in length, illustrating why their classroom will benefit from a 3M SCP712 Projection System. Because teachers are encouraged to help students with this collaborative project, 3M has developed lesson plans to make it easier for teachers to incorporate this project into their everyday curriculum.


Personal Teacher Appreciation Day

Teachers will receive a customized prize package, including a year’s worth of classroom supplies; gift certificates to local restaurants and entertainment; and an NPH research-based intervention program.  Participants can enter the NPH "Teacher Appreciation Day" contest by answering a simple survey and writing a short essay describing why they or someone they know deserves their own personal appreciation day. 


Laura Bush 21st Century Librarian Grant

The Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS) invites proposals from libraries, archives, and library agencies, associations, and consortia for the Laura Bush 21st Century Librarian grant program.