States struggle over how to evaluate special-ed teachers

Kevin Kumashiro, a professor at the University of Illinois in Chicago, was one of 88 professors who recently signed a letter raising questions about Chicago’s plans. In an interview, Kumashiro said there has been a trend when high stakes are placed on standardized test scores: Students who require special services are either turned away or not tested.

“And neither situation is really good,” Kumashiro said.

In Florida, the stakes have already been set: 50 percent of teacher evaluations this school year will be based on student growth. For Campbell, that will consist of the school-wide average of students who do take the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test—students she has no involvement in teaching.

“We’re trying to implement something that wasn’t well thought out, and now the clock is ticking,” said Mark Pudlow, a spokesman for Florida’s statewide teachers union. “It’s a real problem.”

For more school reform news, see:

Why Khan Academy is so popular—and why teachers shouldn’t feel threatened

How corporations can really support U.S. public education

School Reform Center at eSN Online

On a recent morning, Campbell took her students at Amelia Earhart Elementary School in Hialeah, Fla., through their exercises. She put on a song and spent time with each student, saying their name, and encouraging them to look into a mirror and repeat it. Next she read from a giant book, about a third her size, about farm animals causing a ruckus in a house.

She went around the room with a small board that had images of a cow, horse, and duck. She asked them to point to the cow. Some of the students chose the right image, but others didn’t. Some looked off in another direction, delighted by the attention, but unable to respond to the question.

For others, she helped guide their hand to the right answer.

“It’s taken them a long time, and they’re just starting to get these three,” she said.

Campbell marvels at what others might see as tiny, insignificant improvements. She likes teaching students others might give up on, sometimes even their parents. One autistic student in her class came in unable to say his name and hardly spoke any words. Now he’s reciting many letters of the alphabet, and words such as window and couch. Another child, confined to a wheelchair, used to scream and cry all day. Now she stays calm and follows the activities. A child with Down syndrome has begun correctly identifying pictures.

“These are little things,” she said, “but it’s a lot.”

Want to share a great resource? Let us know at