As ED’s report suggests, districts need more guidance on using data to improve instruction–and here’s where the federal government can help. ED should lead by example, using the report’s findings to inform its own practices. It can do this by identifying and holding up models of effective data-use projects that other districts can learn from.
Shortly after the Houston school board approved its new policy by a 7-0 vote, Superintendent Terry Grier told me he was meeting with the union president to discuss the district’s plan. He said many details still had to be worked out, such as how the district would decide which teachers need intervention and what that support would entail. He said he would solicit teachers’ feedback on these areas and hopes to earn their trust.
“We want a [high-] quality teacher in every classroom,” Grier said, adding that teachers whose students consistently underperform shouldn’t be given tenure if they can’t improve or are unwilling to try. “In the process, we don’t want to mistreat anyone, and we don’t want to be unfair.”
How districts use data to improve the quality of teaching in their classrooms–as a blunt instrument of force or a finely nuanced system for change–will go a long way toward developing this trust.
Districts should work collaboratively with unions in designing their data-use programs. At the same time, the unions must be willing to come to the table as well.
As of press time, the American Federation of Teachers had not granted Laura’s repeated requests for an interview for her story. Here’s hoping the unions are more willing partners in negotiating change than the AFT was in responding to an editor’s questions.
- ISTE launches four new initiatives to improve edtech experiences - June 30, 2025
- Study: AI detection software varies in effectiveness - June 3, 2025
- How will schools replace devices bought during the pandemic? - April 1, 2025
