How far should policy makers go in trying to protect kids online?


“My daughter (age 14, entering 9th grade) came home from cheerleading practice this morning absolutely fuming because [her] coach told them that she would no longer be able to communicate with the girls via text [messaging] because of the new Missouri law. As my daughter said, ‘It’s absurd!’ And as I parent, I totally agree. … Don’t [lawmakers] have more pressing issues to worry about?” wrote a Kirkwood, Mo., parent.

“Some people communicate inappropriately; so shall we outlaw communication for all? Some drive dangerously; shall we ban cars? Telephones have been used to scam the elderly; should we get rid of all phones? Whenever anything is misused by a few people with nefarious [intentions], let’s eliminate the rights of all people, good or bad, to use it for anything. Or perhaps somebody should simply explain to Missouri legislators what it means to throw out the baby with the bathwater,” a reader identified as mathonline wrote.

Another reader, jfbenama, wrote: “So does this law take into account a parent who has [his or her] own child, or relative, in class? Can [this teacher] no longer have a private Facebook conversation with [the student/relative]? What about students who you also deal with in other settings, such as church? Can a youth leader, who is also a teacher, no longer chat with youth members? All you’ve done is tied the hands of good educators and forced the child predators to go back to using the telephone and private face-to-face meetings. Social networking isn’t the problem—I wonder how many of those legislators handle their own Facebook account, or have ever really worked with today’s teenagers?”

Aimée M. Bissonette, J.D., a lawyer at Little Buffalo Law & Consulting in Richfield, Minn., said Missouri’s new law shows there needs to be clear boundaries and rules established for teacher-student electronic communication.

“Teachers need to think about what prompted Missouri’s legislature to pass this law,” she wrote. “Many of the problems that have resulted from student-teacher interaction on social networking sites could have been avoided if the teachers involved had worked to create clear separation between their personal and school-related roles. I speak frequently at conferences and faculty development workshops on this very issue. I urge schools to have frank discussions with teachers and staff about privacy issues and the need to be smart and set limits. Communication with students doesn’t have to be banned, but there are ‘best practices’ teachers should embrace.”

Bissonette listed examples of these best practices, such as:

Sign up for our K-12 newsletter

Name
Newsletter: Innovations in K12 Education
By submitting your information, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

eSchool News Staff

Want to share a great resource? Let us know at submissions@eschoolmedia.com.

Comments are closed.

eSchool News uses cookies to improve your experience. Visit our Privacy Policy for more information.