Mon, Aug 11, 2008 Bookmark and Share eMail this Article Send Print this Article Print Media Kit Reprints RSS feeds RSS
Postyourtest.com raises ethical concerns
California-based web site called ‘worrisome’ by some

 

Primary Topic Channel:  Campus-based

 

Students are posting their exams online, and educators are concerned about cheating.

As a student at St. Louis University, Demir Oral met students acing exams partly because they had access to a bank of previous tests from the same professor. Fraternities and sororities had compiled exams from prior years and made them available to students, providing an invaluable study tool during pressure-packed final exams.

So last November, Oral launched Postyourtest.com, starting a free online service that he hoped would democratize the sharing of college exams. And as the site has attracted attention from students nationwide, educators have become wary of the potential for academic dishonesty.

Experts say sites like Postyourtest.com could change the way professors assemble their tests, aware that previous versions of their questions might be available in cyberspace.

"I don't think that should just be available to a few students," said Oral, 23, who operates the web site from San Diego. "That should be available to everyone."

Oral said there are more than 500 tests posted on his web site, with most of them coming from the San Diego area, where Postyourtest.com is advertised. Tests from schools such as the University of Houston, Rice University, Harvard, and Notre Dame are also posted on Oral's site. Critics compare Postyourtest.com to web sites that sell term papers--charging students more than $10 per page in some cases--but Oral said that comparison is unfair. Exams on Postyourtest.com only give students a better idea of what might appear on their upcoming test, he said--they don't supply students with a cheat sheet.

"There's a certain difference there," he said. "I'm not giving a student answers to an exam that's coming up."

Oral's position notwithstanding, Clemson University's Center for Academic Integrity has warned college officials of the cheating potential of Postyourtest.com.

Stephen Satris, the interim director of the Center for Academic Integrity, said many college professors distribute identical exams year after year, allowing students to simply memorize answers--for both multiple- choice and short-answer questions--instead of studying the class material and lecture notes. The proliferation of sites that post exams could shake longtime college faculty members from their malaise and force them to create brand-new tests every semester. 

"Yes, [web sites like Postyourtest.com are] worrisome, partly because we can be pretty sure that not all instructors are changing their tests every semester, as they should," Satris said in an eMail message to eSchool News. "It should be something of a wake-up call. We should assume that if we've given a test, then the test is somewhere out there. These sorts of sites bring that message home to faculty."

He added: "With sites like these online, instructors will be more likely to change their tests more often; the unintended consequence is that if instructors change their tests more often, then sites like this will become less valuable."

 
Continued
Pages: 1 2 | Next ››
 
 

Comment now.

Don't forget to check out our Online highlights:
- Discover new resources that help school leaders strengthen their school district inside our new Superintendents Center.
Go to http://www.eschoolnews.com/news/superintendents-center/
- View this week's Student Video News Cast at www.eschoolnews.tv where you can also upload video too!
- Follow eSchool News on Twitter at http://twitter.com/eschoolnews
- Add our RSS feeds or our new widgets to any school web site. Go to http://www.eschoolnews.com/content-exchange-rss/
- Find the latest news in the current issue of eSchool News. Go to http://www.eschoolnews.com/current/

Copyright problem

To post a test in any form created by a teacher without that teacher's permission would be a flagrant copyright law violation. The posters of these documents had better beware.

Posted By: hotnhumid, 2008-08-14 3:43 PM

21st Century tools

As a teacher, it is easy to see why teachers would prefer the use of multiple choice or closed ended question tests. Essay type or open ended questions exam correction is slower and can lead to subjective evaluations that are debatable, whereas closed questions are objective, quicker to correct and hardly debatable (unless you are really bad at creating this type of questions). Which takes me to the next comment on this issue: while essay type question tests are very easy and quick to make, the closed question and multiple choice ones are not easy at all, they require lots of planning and execution to develop and mostly get refined to excellence by use; which would explain why teachers get attached to their creations for a long time. The other side, as a student, I have a great dislike for multiple choice tests; mostly because their creators don’t really know how to develop them and greatly because the concept is devious. Let’s see, the principle is that there should be 1 correct answer(although not too outwardly right to be singled out immediately) , one that is absolutely wrong but would sound right to someone who knows nothing about the subject and then 2 or 3 more created as “distracters”. Yes, that’s it! These distracters are created with the sole purpose to measure the height of your in-between-knowledge in case you don’t spot the right one, by giving you wrong answers that look right because of carefully placed clauses or modifiers. This amounts to using trickery to see if you fall into a trap, and in student survival I can see why trying to study from a certain teacher’s tests would make sense. Having stated the above, Sartris position, "The site seems more focused on enabling users to get to the test that they might have to face with a given instructor than it is on providing learning guidelines about the things that are important enough in the course to appear on a test.", although learning guidelines about the things that are important enough in the course to appear on a test is clearly the middle point we would all hope for, it fails to recognize that each teacher has a different style, these are not standardized tests we are talking about; therefore, although it’s great to have different styles of the same type of question for one subject, effectiveness by working on the precise style of your teacher will teach you how to identify which questions are relevant to him (her)and how right answers can be identified, learning by doing, hands on. Isn’t that the real way to learn? Teachers have to wake up to the fact that this is a Globalized World, no kidding! And that they have to keep up refreshing their courses, contents, procedures and tests to the demands of this new world. Having their tests out there for others to use and study can turn into an enriching collaborative opportunity where they can improve on their testing style and contribute to others, while helping their students develop the skills necessary to function, clear obstacles and solve problems in the 21st century, with 21st century tools available to them.

Posted By: gviller, 2008-08-12 12:38 PM

Reguritation is for babies, not college

Standard regurgitation of information is not considered quality adult education. College level tests, should expect the students to apply what they learned in class. They should be essay type tests, not multiple choice. Regurgitation is for those high stakes standardized tests that have turned our K-12 schools into miserable test preparation centers that Bush ordered under No Child Left Behind. College professors need to learn to be facilitators of learning. Then maybe the principles of andragogy will filter down to K12 and our kids will start learning again. (Once the conservatives are out of office of course.)

Posted By: twinkie1cat, 2008-08-11 10:51 PM

The Best Way to Test

Testing should not be the game it has become at the post-secondary level. Granted, there are those professors who DO take the approach mentioned by mdmegary above. Unfortunately, however, they are few and far between.

Posted By: bkick, 2008-08-11 12:30 PM

Post-secondary Exams

The fact that universities and colleges are upset about this deals directly with the issue of education at these institutions. It is unfortunate that most college instructors have never been taught how to teach nor how to assess what their students have learned. Most use multiple choice formats which only require students to memorize facts and regurgitate, and never address higher level thinking. If they were truly teaching, they would start the class by telling students what skills they will be required to demonstate at the end of the course and assess those skills at the end of the course. No surprises, no cramming, and no way to cheat.

Posted By: mdmegary, 2008-08-11 12:03 PM

 

You need to be registered at eSchoolnews.com to add your comments. If you do not have a username / password please register here ! Registration is very simple and will not take much time!

 
Already registered? Login:
Username:  Want to know more?
Registation Benefits
Password: